Tip:
“But isn’t that a classic ‘Straw Man argument’”?
or
” Don’t go setting up a ‘Straw-man argument on me!”
Use of this phrase can trip up some of the best conversationalists. This is because, even if you use it spuriously, even if you don’t fully know what it means, most intelligent people will be forced to backtrack over their words to see if they did, in fact, use a straw-man argument. Most of us suck at arguing. So, unless someone has been formally trained in debate, they naturally make straw man arguments all the time. So, after putting even the most intelligent opponent back on his or her heels with this accusation, you can launch into your own mystical mangling of the rules of logic. You will look like you took some kick-ass logic courses in college. Your opponent, in their hesitation, will look guilty to onlookers, even if their hesitation is pausing to wonder if you even know what you just said.
Only conversational weaklings allow others to pull straw-mans on them. Dropping this bomb a few times will establish you as someone who can’t be pushed around in conversation.
Also, like any phrase of this type, as you use it more and more, you will eventually figure out what it means and be much wiser for it. So a few people have to suffer while you hone this skill. Its worth it!
read about the straw-man fallacy at the
Fallacy Files.
When your opponent sets up a straw man, set it on fire and kick the cinders around the stage. Don’t worry about losing the Strawperson-American community vote.
-James Lileks
If you follow my tip, you run the risk of actually kicking around a valid argument, but I’m betting you can get away with it. At worst, someone weeks later will be lying awake in bed realizing that you pulled a fast one. By then, it will be too late!